Broker Alarab
Broker Comparison

Admirals vs XS: Which Broker Is Better?

Compare Admirals and XS across fees, spreads, regulation, account types, trading platforms and overall suitability for different trading needs.

Best Overall
XS
Overall Rating
Best for Beginners
Admirals
Costs and Execution
XS
Direct Comparison

Admirals vs XS

VS
Admirals logo

Admirals

4.26out of 5
Best Suited For

MetaTrader and analytical tools

XS logo

XS

4.52out of 5
Best Suited For

MetaTrader and multi-asset access

Broker Alarab View
Our View on Admirals▼

Admirals is designed for MetaTrader users who want access to Trade and Zero accounts, MT4 and MT5, together with additional analytical tools and platform features.

It suits traders who want a choice between spread-based and commission-based pricing, although account availability, payment methods and regulatory protection depend on the client’s country and assigned entity.

Our View on XS▼

XS offers a range of account types, from Micro and Standard accounts to Pro and Elite structures, allowing traders to compare spreads, minimum deposits and trading conditions according to their experience and trading volume.

It may suit MT4 and MT5 users seeking flexible execution conditions, although advanced accounts generally require more capital and a clear understanding of their commission and pricing structure.

Score Analysis

Strength Comparison

Compare Admirals and XS across the main factors traders consider when choosing a broker.

Comparison Factor
Admirals
XS

Safety & Trust

4.55
4.40

Fees & Costs

4.15
4.50

Trading Platforms

4.40
4.40

Deposits & Withdrawals

4.05
4.50

Customer Support

4.15
4.35

Small score differences do not mean the brokers are identical. Choose according to the factor that matters most to you, such as regulation, trading costs, platforms, withdrawals or customer support.

Accounts & Trading Costs

Compare Accounts and Fees

Compare account types, spreads, commissions and minimum deposits at Admirals and XS.

Quick Cost Comparison
XS

XS shows an advantage in trading costs or spreads based on the available data.

Admirals
2
available accounts
XS
5
available accounts
Ease of Entry
Best for Beginners
Admirals
Comparison
Admirals
XS
Main Account
Trade
Standard
Minimum Deposit
$100
$0
Spread
0.5 - 1.2
1.1 – 1.8
Commission
$0
$0
Execution
Market Execution
Market Execution
Account Details

Explore Available Account Types

Open each broker to compare the spread, commission, deposit and execution method for every account.

Admirals Accounts

2 available accounts

▼
Trade

Commission-free general trading

Details
Spread
0.5 - 1.2
Commission
$0
Deposit
$100
Execution: Market Execution
Zero

Scalpers and active traders

Details
Spread
0.0 - 0.3
Commission
From $3.6 per lot
Deposit
$100
Execution: Market Execution

XS Accounts

5 available accounts

▼
Spread
1.1 – 1.8
Commission
$0
Deposit
No minimum deposit
Execution: Market Execution
Micro

General traders

Details
Spread
1.1 – 1.8
Commission
$0
Deposit
No minimum deposit
Execution: Market Execution
Cent

General traders

Details
Spread
1.1 – 1.8
Commission
$0
Deposit
No minimum deposit
Execution: Market Execution
Pro

General traders

Details
Spread
0.6 – 1.0
Commission
$0
Deposit
$500
Execution: Market Execution
Elite

Scalping

Details
Spread
0.0 – 0.2
Commission
$6 per lot
Deposit
$500
Execution: Market Execution

Do not choose a broker based only on the number of accounts. Compare spreads, commissions, minimum deposits and execution methods before selecting a trading account.

Choose the Broker That Fits Your Trading

Continue after reviewing the available accounts and trading costs.

Safety & Regulation

Compare Broker Safety

Admirals vs XS

Compare safety scores, regulators and the legal entity responsible for each trading account.

Admirals
4.55
Safety score out of 5
XS
4.40
Safety score out of 5
Admirals
3 licencesIslamic account
XS
8 licencesIslamic account

The number of licences alone is not enough. Verify the legal entity that will hold your account.

Admirals logo
Regulatory Profile

Admirals Licences

3 registered licences • 4.55 out of 5

▼
Headquarters
Tallinn, Estonia
Islamic Account
Available

Regulators

3 records
CySECStrong oversight
Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission
Licence Number
201/13
Legal Entity
Admirals Europe Ltd
FCAStrong oversight
Financial Conduct Authority
Licence Number
595450
Legal Entity
Admiral Markets UK Ltd
United Kingdom
Official Check
JSCModerate oversight
Jordan Securities Commission
Licence Number
1/3/01970/21
Legal Entity
Admiral Markets AS Jordan Ltd
Regulation and Fund Protection
Read the full analysis
▼

Regulatory Summary

Admirals operates through entities that include Admiral Markets UK Ltd, authorised by the UK FCA under licence number 595450, and Admirals Europe Ltd, regulated by CySEC under licence number 201/13. The group also includes Admiral Markets AS Jordan Ltd, registered with the Jordan Securities Commission, providing a direct regulatory presence in the Arab region.

The Jordanian entity may be relevant to eligible traders in the region, but the account may be opened with a different company depending on the client’s country and available services. Trade and Zero accounts, leverage, products, complaint procedures and legal protection can vary between entities under the same Admirals brand.

Before opening an Admirals account, traders should match the legal entity and licence number in the client agreement with the regulator’s official register. This helps Arabic-speaking traders understand whether their account is assigned to the Jordanian, European or UK entity and assess the actual protection that applies.

Client Fund Protection at Admirals

Regulated Admirals entities hold eligible retail client funds in segregated accounts, separate from the money used for the company’s operations. Negative balance protection may also apply under the conditions of the relevant entity. Eligible clients registered with certain UK or European entities may qualify for statutory compensation or additional legal safeguards within defined limits.

These protections do not automatically apply to every Admirals account worldwide. Client-money rules, compensation eligibility and complaint procedures may differ between the Jordanian, UK, European and international entities. Traders should confirm the legal company named in their client agreement and review the protection available under that entity before depositing.

XS logo
Regulatory Profile

XS Licences

8 registered licences • 4.40 out of 5

▼
Headquarters
Sydney, Australia
Islamic Account
Available

Regulators

8 records
ASICStrong oversight
Australian Securities and Investments Commission
Licence Number
374409
Legal Entity
XS Prime Ltd
CySECStrong oversight
Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission
Licence Number
412/22
Legal Entity
XS Markets Ltd
FSCAModerate oversight
Financial Sector Conduct Authority
Licence Number
53199
Legal Entity
XS ZA (Pty) Ltd
South Africa
Official Check
SCAModerate oversight
Securities and Commodities Authority
Licence Number
20200000339
Legal Entity
XSTrade Financial Consultation L.L.C
United Arab Emirates
No verification link
FSAInternational oversight
Financial Services Authority Seychelles
Licence Number
SD089
Legal Entity
XS Ltd
Seychelles
Official Check
FSC MauritiusInternational oversight
Financial Services Commission Mauritius
Licence Number
GB25204786
Legal Entity
XS Trade Services Ltd
LFSAInternational oversight
Labuan Financial Services Authority
Licence Number
MB/21/0081
Legal Entity
XS Finance Ltd
Malaysia
No verification link
MOCI KuwaitInternational oversight
Ministry of Commerce and Industry - Kuwait
Licence Number
2024/786
Legal Entity
XS Online
Regulation and Fund Protection
Read the full analysis
▼

Regulatory Summary

XS operates through a broad regulatory structure that includes XS Prime Ltd, authorised by ASIC under licence number 374409, and XS Markets Ltd, regulated by CySEC under licence number 412/22, together with entities supervised by the FSCA in South Africa, the FSA in Seychelles, the FSC in Mauritius and the LFSA in Malaysia. The group also has registrations or related entities connected to the UAE and Kuwait, reflecting its international reach.

Traders should distinguish between a full financial-services licence and registrations or authorisations with a different scope. The appearance of the XS name in a local register does not necessarily provide the same level of protection available under ASIC or CySEC, and trading conditions, leverage and complaint procedures may vary according to the legal company accepting the account.

When researching XS licences, the number of regulators listed is not enough. Traders should identify the specific entity they will contract with and verify its number in the official register. ASIC and CySEC entities may be more suitable for traders prioritising strict oversight, while some international entities may offer greater flexibility under a different level of regulatory protection.

Client Fund Protection at XS

XS applies client fund protection measures according to the regulatory entity responsible for each account. These measures include separating eligible client money from company operating funds, together with controls related to deposits, withdrawals, identity verification and anti-money-laundering requirements. XS agreements also provide negative balance protection under the applicable conditions.

Negative balance protection may limit liability from losses exceeding the available trading-account balance, but legal safeguards are not identical across all entities. Investor compensation eligibility, complaint procedures and client-money protection may differ between the ASIC, CySEC and international entities in Seychelles, Mauritius and other jurisdictions. Traders should verify their legal company before depositing.

Before depositing, match the legal entity and licence number in your client agreement with the regulator’s official register.

Comparison Summary

Which Broker Fits You?

Choose based on your priorities, not the overall rating alone.

Overall Result
XS

XS has the higher overall rating, but review why each broker may suit you before deciding.

Easier Start
Admirals
Fees & Costs
XS
Admirals logo
Alternative Choice by Priority

Admirals

4.26
out of 5
Choose This Broker If You Want

Trade and Zero accounts with MetaTrader trading tools

MetaTrader tradersExpert Advisor users
Important

Account availability, client protection and payment methods vary by country and entity

XS logo
Best Choice by Overall Rating

XS

4.52
out of 5
Choose This Broker If You Want

Flexible account range from Micro to Pro and Elite

Low-deposit tradersMicro account users
Important

Advanced accounts may require higher deposits and stricter trading conditions

Final Decision
Broker Alarab View

XS offers a range of account types, from Micro and Standard accounts to Pro and Elite structures, allowing traders to compare spreads, minimum deposits and trading conditions according to their experience and trading volume.

Check the account conditions, fees and regulatory entity available in your country before registering.

Frequently Asked Questions

Questions About Admirals and XS

Important answers before opening an account or choosing the more suitable broker.

Admirals
XS

Questions About Admirals

3 questions

Why does Admirals list Trade and Zero accounts separately for MT4 and MT5?

▼

Trade.MT4 and Trade.MT5 use broadly similar pricing on different platforms, as do Zero.MT4 and Zero.MT5. They can therefore be grouped as Trade and Zero while listing platform availability separately.

Is the Admirals Zero account always cheaper than Trade?

▼

Zero offers spreads from 0.0 pips with a separate commission, while Trade includes broker costs in the spread. The cheaper option depends on live spreads, trade size and trading frequency.

What is Admirals Invest.MT5 and why is it not listed as a forex account?

▼

Invest.MT5 is designed for eligible investment products under different conditions. It is not the same category as the Trade and Zero forex and CFD pricing accounts.

Questions About XS

3 questions

What account types does XS offer and which one is best?

▼

XS offers multiple account types including Standard, Cent, Micro, Pro, Elite, and VIP. Beginners usually start with Standard or Cent accounts, while experienced traders prefer Elite or Pro accounts for lower spreads.

Is XS a legit broker or should traders be cautious?

▼

XS operates under multiple regulatory licenses such as ASIC and CySEC, but not all entities are considered top-tier. Traders should always check the specific regulatory entity before opening an account.

Does XS really allow trading with no minimum deposit?

▼

Yes, XS offers accounts like Standard, Micro, and Cent with no minimum deposit requirement, allowing traders to start with very small amounts.

Conditions may vary by country and regulatory entity. Review the account details before registering.