Account One01
Direct STP
Advertised Spread
1.2 - 1.6
Commission
$0
Minimum Deposit
$50
Detailed Trading Account Comparison
Trading Account Comparison: Moneta Markets Direct STPvs Tickmill Classic
Explore differences in spreads, commissions, deposits and trading conditions, alongside a detailed review of each account's advantages and limitations.
Account Two02
Classic
Advertised Spread
1.6 - 2.0
Commission
$0
Minimum Deposit
$100
ACCOUNT OVERVIEW
What Makes Moneta Markets Direct STP Different from Tickmill Classic?
Before comparing the numbers, it is important to understand the purpose of each account and the conditions that may make it suitable for different traders.
Moneta Markets Direct STP
The Moneta Markets Direct STP account is categorized by Broker Alarab for beginners and traders who prefer commission-free pricing. According to our data, spreads range from 1.2–1.6 pips with a recorded average of 1.4 pips, the separate commission is $0, the minimum deposit is $50 and the account uses STP Execution. Direct STP differs from Prime ECN and Ultra ECN through spread-based pricing without a separate commission.
Tickmill Classic
The Tickmill Classic account is the broker’s simpler trading-cost model, charging no separate commission and placing the primary transaction cost within the spread. According to Broker Alarab data, spreads range from 1.6–2.0 pips, commission is $0, the minimum deposit is $100 and orders use Market Execution, making Classic a straightforward option for beginners and general traders.
SIDE-BY-SIDE COMPARISON
Compare Trading Accounts, Spreads, Commissions and Platforms
Review spreads, commissions, minimum deposits, trading platforms, execution methods and broker-level regulatory information.
Moneta Markets
Direct STP
Tickmill
Classic
01 — Basic Account Information
Compare the broker, account name, account classification and regulatory information.
Broker
Moneta Markets
Moneta Markets
Tickmill
Tickmill
Account Name
Moneta Markets
Direct STP
Tickmill
Classic
Account Type
Moneta Markets
standard
Tickmill
standard
Broker Regulatory Licenses
Broker-level regulatory information. Verify which legal entity serves your country.
Moneta Markets
FCA | FSCA | FSC
Tickmill
FCA | CySEC | FSCA | FSA
02 — Spreads and Trading Costs
Compare the recorded trading costs without assuming undocumented pricing.
Advertised Spread Range
Moneta Markets
1.2 - 1.6
Tickmill
1.6 - 2.0
Minimum Recorded Spread
Based on the available account information.
Moneta Markets
1.2
Tickmill
1.6
Average Recorded Spread
Moneta Markets
1.4
Tickmill
1.8
Advertised Commission
Moneta Markets
$0
Tickmill
$0
03 — Deposits and Execution
Review account funding requirements and order execution characteristics.
Minimum Deposit
Moneta Markets
$50
Tickmill
$100
Order Execution Method
Moneta Markets
STP Execution
Tickmill
Market Execution
Trading Platforms
Available platforms may differ by account type.
Moneta Markets
MT4 | MT5 | AppTrader
Tickmill
MT4 | MT5 | TradingView
04 — Account Features and Conditions
Review relevant account characteristics and trading suitability.
Scalping Suitability
An internal classification, not a guarantee of suitability.
Moneta Markets
Not classified in this category
Tickmill
Not classified in this category
05 — Broker Information and Regulation
Broker-level information does not guarantee that every license applies to the selected account.
Listed Regulatory Licenses
Moneta Markets
FCA | FSCA | FSC
Tickmill
FCA | CySEC | FSCA | FSA
Broker Maximum Leverage
Actual leverage may depend on the account, jurisdiction and legal entity.
Moneta Markets
1:1000
Tickmill
1:1000
Open a Trading Account
Moneta Markets
Open Account ↗Tickmill
Open Account ↗Information is based on records available to Broker Alarab. Trading conditions may vary by account, country and legal entity.
| Comparison Criteria | Moneta Markets Direct STP | Tickmill Classic |
|---|---|---|
01 — Basic Account Information Compare the broker, account name, account classification and regulatory information. | ||
| Broker | Moneta Markets | Tickmill |
| Account Name | Direct STP | Classic |
| Account Type | standard | standard |
| Broker Regulatory Licenses Broker-level regulatory information. Verify which legal entity serves your country. | FCA | FSCA | FSC | FCA | CySEC | FSCA | FSA |
02 — Spreads and Trading Costs Compare the recorded trading costs without assuming undocumented pricing. | ||
| Advertised Spread Range | 1.2 - 1.6 | 1.6 - 2.0 |
| Minimum Recorded Spread Based on the available account information. | 1.2 | 1.6 |
| Average Recorded Spread | 1.4 | 1.8 |
| Advertised Commission | $0 | $0 |
03 — Deposits and Execution Review account funding requirements and order execution characteristics. | ||
| Minimum Deposit | $50 | $100 |
| Order Execution Method | STP Execution | Market Execution |
| Trading Platforms Available platforms may differ by account type. | MT4 | MT5 | AppTrader | MT4 | MT5 | TradingView |
04 — Account Features and Conditions Review relevant account characteristics and trading suitability. | ||
| Scalping Suitability An internal classification, not a guarantee of suitability. | Not classified in this category | Not classified in this category |
05 — Broker Information and Regulation Broker-level information does not guarantee that every license applies to the selected account. | ||
| Listed Regulatory Licenses | FCA | FSCA | FSC | FCA | CySEC | FSCA | FSA |
| Broker Maximum Leverage Actual leverage may depend on the account, jurisdiction and legal entity. | 1:1000 | 1:1000 |
| Open a Trading Account | Open Account ↗ | Open Account ↗ |
Information is presented as recorded by Broker Alarab. Spread and commission figures should not be treated as directly comparable without verifying the instrument, pricing units and fee structure.
EXPERT ANALYSIS
Broker Alarab's Assessment of Both Accounts
We review each account independently, highlighting strengths, limitations and the types of traders it may suit, without declaring an unsupported winner.
Moneta Markets
Direct STP
Tickmill
Classic
Broker Alarab's Assessment
We see Moneta Markets Direct STP as distinguished by its straightforward pricing and accessible entry requirement: a $50 minimum deposit and $0 separate commission. The trade-off is a recorded 1.2–1.6 pip spread range, wider than the ECN accounts. It is therefore more relevant to traders prioritizing simple pricing over obtaining the tightest possible spread.
Broker Alarab's Assessment
We see Tickmill Classic as better suited to traders who prioritize pricing simplicity over obtaining the tightest possible spreads. Zero separate commission makes the account easy to understand for beginners and general traders, but its 1.6–2.0 pip range makes comparison with Raw important. As trading volume and frequency increase, total cost matters more than the commission-free label.
Account Advantages
- ✓No separate trading commission according to Broker Alarab data
- ✓Minimum deposit is $50
- ✓Categorized for beginners and commission-free trading
- ✓Straightforward pricing based primarily on the spread
- ✓Substantially lower deposit requirement than Ultra ECN
Account Advantages
- ✓No separate trading commission according to Broker Alarab data
- ✓Straightforward pricing model based primarily on the spread
- ✓The minimum deposit is $100 according to our data
- ✓Categorized for beginners and general traders in our account data
- ✓Makes transaction costs easier to understand without adding a per-lot commission
Disadvantages and Considerations
- !The recorded spread range is wider than Prime ECN and Ultra ECN
- !No separate commission does not mean trading is cost-free
- !The 1.2-pip minimum does not represent the complete recorded spread range
- !Active traders should compare total costs with Prime ECN
Disadvantages and Considerations
- !The 1.6–2.0 pip spread range is wider than Raw in our data
- !Zero commission does not mean cost-free trading because cost remains within the spread
- !The spread difference can become more significant with frequent or larger-volume trading
- !Spread-sensitive traders should compare Classic directly with Raw before choosing
Who Is This Account Suitable For?
- •Beginners according to Broker Alarab account categorization
- •Traders who prefer pricing without a separate commission
- •Users seeking a Moneta account with a $50 minimum deposit
- •Traders who prefer a cost structure based primarily on the spread
Who Is This Account Suitable For?
- •Beginners seeking a Tickmill account with straightforward pricing
- •General traders who prefer not to pay a separate per-lot commission
- •Lower-frequency traders who are not focused exclusively on the tightest possible spread
- •Traders who prefer evaluating spread cost without an additional commission component
Detailed Account Analysis
Moneta Direct STP vs Prime ECN: How Does Pricing Differ?
Both accounts have a $50 minimum deposit in Broker Alarab data, but their pricing structures differ. Direct STP has recorded spreads of 1.2–1.6 pips with a 1.4-pip average and no separate commission, while Prime ECN has 0.0–0.3 pip spreads with a 0.1-pip average and a $6 per-lot commission. Total costs should therefore be compared according to trading style and volume.
Is the Moneta Markets Direct STP Account Commission-Free?
The separate commission recorded for Direct STP by Broker Alarab is $0. This does not mean trading cost is zero because the recorded spread ranges from 1.2–1.6 pips with a 1.4-pip average. The spread is therefore the primary listed component when evaluating account costs.
What Is the Moneta Direct STP Minimum Deposit?
The recorded minimum deposit is $50, the same requirement recorded for Prime ECN and substantially below the $20,000 required for Ultra ECN. This figure represents an account requirement and should not be interpreted as a recommendation for suitable trading capital or risk management.
Detailed Account Analysis
Tickmill Classic vs Raw: Which Account Is Better?
This is the key comparison when choosing a Tickmill account. According to Broker Alarab data, Classic has a 1.6–2.0 pip spread range with no separate commission, while Raw is listed at 0.0–0.3 pips with a $6-per-lot commission. Both accounts have a $100 minimum deposit, so the decision is not driven by the capital required to open the account. Classic provides simpler pricing, while Raw substantially reduces the spread. The better account depends on lot size, trading frequency and the total cost produced by each model.
Is the Tickmill Classic Account Good for Beginners?
Broker Alarab categorizes Classic for beginners and general traders, and one reason is the simplicity of its cost structure. There is no separate per-lot trading commission, leaving the spread as the primary transaction cost traders need to monitor when opening and closing positions. This simplicity does not make trading less risky or guarantee that Classic is always cheaper. Its main advantage for newer traders is making trading costs easier to understand before moving to models that combine spreads and commissions.
Does Zero Commission Make Tickmill Classic Cheaper?
Not necessarily. Commission-free pricing means there is no separate trading charge per lot, but it does not remove spread cost. Classic spreads range from 1.6–2.0 pips in our data, compared with 0.0–0.3 pips on Raw, which carries a separate commission. Lower-frequency traders may value Classic’s simplicity, while active traders need to calculate the spread difference and commission against their actual volume. Total transaction cost matters more than commission alone.
Important details about the Moneta Markets Direct STP account
The separate commission is $0
There is no separate trading commission according to Broker Alarab data, but the 1.2–1.6 pip spread remains a direct component of trading cost.
The recorded average spread is 1.4 pips
The recorded minimum is 1.2 pips and the range extends to 1.6 pips, so both the range and average provide more context than the starting figure alone.
The minimum deposit is $50
This is the account requirement recorded in our data, the same as Prime ECN, and it is not a recommendation for appropriate trading capital.
Important details about the Tickmill Classic account
Commission-free does not mean cost-free
Classic has no separate trading commission in our data, but its 1.6–2.0 pip spread range remains a central component of transaction cost. The account should therefore not be evaluated using commission alone.
The $100 minimum deposit is not suggested trading capital
Broker Alarab data lists a $100 minimum deposit for Classic. This is an account entry requirement rather than a recommendation for an appropriate trading balance or risk level.
Classic and Raw have the same minimum deposit in our data
Both accounts carry a $100 minimum deposit according to our dataset. The comparison should therefore focus on pricing: wider commission-free spreads on Classic versus tighter spreads with a separate commission on Raw.
DECISION GUIDE
How to Choose the Right Trading Account
Numbers alone are not enough. Account suitability depends on your trading strategy, capital, financial instruments and the conditions applicable to you.
01
Compare Spreads and Commissions Together
The recorded spread for Moneta Markets Direct STP is 1.2 - 1.6, while Tickmill Classic shows 1.6 - 2.0. Evaluating overall trading costs also requires checking commission rates, pricing units, instruments and position sizes.
02
Review Minimum Deposit Requirements
The recorded minimum deposit for Moneta Markets Direct STP is $50, compared with $100 for Tickmill Classic. A lower deposit requirement may provide more flexibility, but it does not automatically make an account better.
03
Compare Trading Platforms and Execution
Check which trading platforms each broker actually offers for the selected account, including MetaTrader 4 or MetaTrader 5 where supported. Also review execution policies and potential slippage. Availability and conditions may vary by account and country.
04
Verify Regulation and Eligibility
Confirm the legal entity that will serve your account, the regulatory framework applicable to that entity, and whether the selected account is available in your country.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
FAQs About Moneta Markets Direct STP vs Tickmill Classic
Answers to common questions about account comparisons, trading costs and account conditions.
What is the difference between Moneta Markets Direct STP and Tickmill Classic?+
The recorded spread for Moneta Markets Direct STP is 1.2 - 1.6, compared with 1.6 - 2.0 for Tickmill Classic. The advertised commissions are $0 and $0, respectively. You should also consider execution conditions, deposit requirements and account availability.
Is the account with the lowest spread always better?+
Not necessarily. Trading costs should be evaluated using both spreads and commissions, while considering the financial instrument, position size and execution conditions.
Can I compare two accounts from the same broker?+
Yes. Broker Alarab allows traders to compare accounts from the same broker or from different brokers.
How can I verify the trading conditions?+
Review the broker's official account specifications, applicable legal entity and trading conditions. Spreads, commissions and leverage may vary by instrument, account and jurisdiction.
What is the Moneta Markets Direct STP account?+
Direct STP is the Moneta Markets account categorized by Broker Alarab for beginners and commission-free trading. According to our data, spreads range from 1.2–1.6 pips with a 1.4-pip recorded average, the separate commission is $0, the minimum deposit is $50 and the account uses STP Execution.
What is the Moneta Direct STP spread?+
The recorded Direct STP spread ranges from 1.2–1.6 pips, while the recorded average is 1.4 pips. Account costs should therefore not be reduced to the 1.2-pip minimum, particularly because the spread is the primary pricing component with no separate commission.
Does Moneta Direct STP charge commission?+
The separate commission recorded by Broker Alarab is $0. This means there is no separate trading commission in our account data, but the 1.2–1.6 pip spread remains part of the cost of opening and closing trades.
What is the difference between Moneta Direct STP and Prime ECN?+
Direct STP has recorded spreads of 1.2–1.6 pips without a separate commission, while Prime ECN has 0.0–0.3 pip spreads with a $6 per-lot commission. Both have a $50 minimum deposit, while Direct STP uses STP Execution and Prime uses ECN Execution.
What is the Tickmill Classic account?+
The Tickmill Classic account uses a commission-free pricing model in which transaction cost is concentrated primarily within the spread. According to Broker Alarab data, spreads range from 1.6–2.0 pips, commission is $0, the minimum deposit is $100 and orders use Market Execution. We categorize the account for beginners and general traders who prefer a straightforward trading-cost structure.
What is the Tickmill Classic spread and commission?+
According to Broker Alarab data, Tickmill Classic spreads range from 1.6–2.0 pips and there is no separate trading commission. The spread therefore represents the primary transaction cost when opening and closing a position. Zero commission does not mean free trading, making the spread range particularly important when comparing Classic with Raw, which offers tighter spreads in exchange for a separate commission.
Explore Both Trading Accounts in Detail
Review the full account information, compare trading conditions and verify the broker's requirements before opening an account.