Broker Alarab
Broker Comparison

ActivTrades vs Vantage: Which Broker Is Better?

Compare ActivTrades and Vantage across fees, spreads, regulation, account types, trading platforms and overall suitability for different trading needs.

Best Overall
ActivTrades
Overall Rating
Best for Beginners
Both are suitable
Costs and Execution
Closely matched
Direct Comparison

ActivTrades vs Vantage

VS
ActivTrades logo

ActivTrades

4.45out of 5
Best Suited For

Strong regulation

Vantage logo

Vantage

4.38out of 5
Best Suited For

Scalping

Broker Alarab View
Our View on ActivTrades

ActivTrades is a strong option for traders who prioritise client protection, regulatory oversight and broker stability, with access to ActivTrader, MT4 and MT5.

It is better suited to cautious and intermediate traders, although spreads and overall trading costs may not be ideal for frequent scalping, so daily trading expenses should be compared carefully.

Our View on Vantage

Vantage offers Standard, Raw ECN and Pro ECN-style accounts, with competitive spreads and MT4 and MT5 access for active forex traders, scalpers and day traders.

It may suit traders who prioritise execution speed and tighter pricing, although commissions, minimum-deposit requirements, leverage conditions and the differences between account types should be compared before registration.

Score Analysis

Strength Comparison

Compare ActivTrades and Vantage across the main factors traders consider when choosing a broker.

Comparison Factor
ActivTrades
Vantage

Safety & Trust

4.75
4.40

Fees & Costs

4.35
4.45

Trading Platforms

4.50
4.45

Deposits & Withdrawals

4.40
4.35

Customer Support

4.40
4.25

Small score differences do not mean the brokers are identical. Choose according to the factor that matters most to you, such as regulation, trading costs, platforms, withdrawals or customer support.

Accounts & Trading Costs

Compare Accounts and Fees

Compare account types, spreads, commissions and minimum deposits at ActivTrades and Vantage.

Quick Cost Comparison
Trading costs are closely matched

Neither broker has a decisive cost advantage, so compare the conditions of each account.

ActivTrades
1
available account
Vantage
3
available accounts
Ease of Entry
Best for Beginners
Both are suitable
Comparison
ActivTrades
Vantage
Main Account
Standard
Standard
Minimum Deposit
$10
$50
Spread
0.8 – 1.2
1.0 – 1.5
Commission
$0
$0
Execution
Market Execution
Market Execution
Account Details

Explore Available Account Types

Open each broker to compare the spread, commission, deposit and execution method for every account.

ActivTrades Accounts

1 available account

Standard

General traders

Details
Spread
0.8 – 1.2
Commission
$0
Deposit
$10
Execution: Market Execution

Vantage Accounts

3 available accounts

Spread
1.0 – 1.5
Commission
$0
Deposit
$50
Execution: Market Execution
Spread
0.0 – 0.3
Commission
$6 per lot
Deposit
$50
Execution: Market Execution
Pro ECN

General traders

Details
Spread
0.0 – 0.2
Commission
$3 per lot
Deposit
$10,000
Execution: Market Execution

Do not choose a broker based only on the number of accounts. Compare spreads, commissions, minimum deposits and execution methods before selecting a trading account.

Choose the Broker That Fits Your Trading

Continue after reviewing the available accounts and trading costs.

ActivTrades
Start Now
Vantage
Start Now
Safety & Regulation

Compare Broker Safety

ActivTrades vs Vantage

Compare safety scores, regulators and the legal entity responsible for each trading account.

ActivTrades
4.75
Safety score out of 5
Vantage
4.40
Safety score out of 5
ActivTrades
6 licencesIslamic account
Vantage
4 licencesIslamic account

The number of licences alone is not enough. Verify the legal entity that will hold your account.

ActivTrades logo
Regulatory Profile

ActivTrades Licences

6 registered licences4.75 out of 5

Headquarters
London, UK
Islamic Account
Available

Regulators

6 records
FCAStrong oversight
Financial Conduct Authority
Licence Number
434413
Legal Entity
ActivTrades PLC
United Kingdom
Official Check
BACENModerate oversight
Central Bank of Brazil
Licence Number
غير محدد
Legal Entity
ActivTrades CCTVM
CMVMModerate oversight
Portuguese Securities Market Commission
Licence Number
433
Legal Entity
ActivMarkets - Empresa de Investimento, S.A.
CVMModerate oversight
Brazilian Securities and Exchange Commission
Licence Number
غير محدد
Legal Entity
ActivTrades CCTVM
FSCInternational oversight
Financial Services Commission
Licence Number
غير محدد
Legal Entity
ActivTrades Mauritius Ltd
SCBInternational oversight
Securities Commission of The Bahamas
Licence Number
199667 B
Legal Entity
ActivTrades Corp
Regulation and Fund Protection
Read the full analysis

Regulatory Summary

ActivTrades operates through a regulatory structure that includes ActivTrades PLC, authorised by the UK FCA under licence number 434413, which is one of the group’s strongest regulated entities. The group also has entities or registrations connected to Portugal and Brazil, as well as international companies linked to Mauritius and the Bahamas, allowing it to serve clients in different markets under different legal frameworks.

Client protection depends on the entity under which the trading account is opened. FCA requirements and UK complaint procedures do not automatically apply to accounts opened with an international entity, and traders should distinguish between a full investment-services licence, local registration and regulatory frameworks with different powers.

Before opening an ActivTrades account, traders should confirm the legal company name and licence number shown during registration, then review the applicable client-money protection, compensation and complaints procedures. This is particularly important for traders choosing ActivTrades for its platforms or operating history.

Client Fund Protection at ActivTrades

ActivTrades client fund protection includes holding eligible client money separately from the company’s operating funds under the rules of the legal entity responsible for the account. Negative balance protection is also available where applicable. The broker additionally advertises client-fund insurance of up to GBP 1 million for certain eligible clients, above the basic statutory protection limits.

This additional insurance is not a general guarantee and remains subject to the policy terms, client eligibility, coverage limits and account entity. Traders should verify the legal company serving their account and review the applicable segregation, compensation and insurance conditions before relying on the advertised protection amount.

Vantage logo
Regulatory Profile

Vantage Licences

4 registered licences4.40 out of 5

Headquarters
Sydney, Australia
Islamic Account
Available

Regulators

4 records
ASICStrong oversight
Australian Securities and Investments Commission
Licence Number
428901
Legal Entity
Vantage Global Prime Pty Ltd
FCAStrong oversight
Financial Conduct Authority
Licence Number
590299
Legal Entity
Vantage Global Prime LLP
United Kingdom
Official Check
CIMAModerate oversight
Cayman Islands Monetary Authority
Licence Number
1383491
Legal Entity
Vantage International Group Limited
Cayman Islands
Official Check
VFSCInternational oversight
Vanuatu Financial Services Commission
Licence Number
700271
Legal Entity
Vantage Global Limited
Regulation and Fund Protection
Read the full analysis

Regulatory Summary

Vantage operates through entities regulated in several jurisdictions, including Vantage Global Prime Pty Ltd, authorised by ASIC under licence number 428901, and Vantage Global Prime LLP, authorised by the UK FCA under licence number 590299. The group also uses international entities supervised by CIMA in the Cayman Islands and the VFSC in Vanuatu for markets not covered by its main entities.

The level of oversight and protection at Vantage depends on the legal company under which the account is opened. FCA and ASIC entities operate under stricter requirements, while international entities may offer higher leverage and more flexible trading conditions with different complaint procedures and legal rights.

When comparing Vantage licences, traders should identify the entity shown in the account-opening agreement and match its number with the regulator’s official register. This is particularly important for traders interested in low-spread accounts or active trading, because attractive trading conditions should always be assessed together with the regulatory protection that actually applies.

Client Fund Protection at Vantage

Vantage client fund protection depends on the legal entity through which the trading account is opened. The Australian entity follows ASIC client-money requirements and states that eligible funds are held in segregated accounts, while other Vantage entities apply the rules of their respective regulators. Negative balance protection may also be available for eligible clients and accounts.

These arrangements do not provide one identical guarantee across the entire Vantage group. Client rights, investor compensation eligibility and complaint procedures may differ between entities regulated by ASIC, FCA, CIMA and VFSC. Traders should verify the company named in their account agreement and the protection applying to their funds before depositing.

Before depositing, match the legal entity and licence number in your client agreement with the regulator’s official register.

Comparison Summary

Which Broker Fits You?

Choose based on your priorities, not the overall rating alone.

Overall Result
The two brokers are closely matched

The difference is limited. Make your decision based on the account, fees and trading platform you need.

Easier Start
Both are suitable
Fees & Costs
Costs are closely matched
ActivTrades logo
Alternative Choice by Priority

ActivTrades

4.45
out of 5
Choose This Broker If You Want

Strong regulatory protection with established trading platforms

BeginnersProfessional traders
Important

Actual trading costs may vary by spread, account type and regulatory entity

Vantage logo
Alternative Choice by Priority

Vantage

4.38
out of 5
Choose This Broker If You Want

Standard, Raw and Pro ECN accounts for different trading needs

ScalpersRaw spread traders
Important

Commission, leverage and deposit requirements vary by account and entity

Final Decision
Broker Alarab View

ActivTrades is a strong option for traders who prioritise client protection, regulatory oversight and broker stability, with access to ActivTrader, MT4 and MT5.

Check the account conditions, fees and regulatory entity available in your country before registering.

Frequently Asked Questions

Questions About ActivTrades and Vantage

Important answers before opening an account or choosing the more suitable broker.

ActivTrades
Vantage

Questions About ActivTrades

3 questions

How competitive are ActivTrades spreads compared to other brokers?

ActivTrades offers spreads typically between 0.8 to 1.2 pips on its Standard account, which is competitive but not the lowest compared to raw spread brokers. However, the absence of commissions makes it attractive for simple trading strategies.

Does ActivTrades charge commissions or is everything included in the spread?

ActivTrades uses a spread-only pricing model for most accounts, meaning there are no separate commissions. All trading costs are built into the spread, making pricing simpler for traders.

What makes ActivTrades different from ECN brokers?

Unlike ECN brokers that offer ultra-low spreads with commissions, ActivTrades provides a simpler model with no commissions and slightly higher spreads, making it more suitable for traders who prefer predictable costs.

Questions About Vantage

3 questions

How competitive are Vantage spreads compared to ECN brokers?

Vantage Standard accounts typically offer spreads between 1.0 to 1.5 pips, while Raw ECN accounts provide much tighter spreads starting from 0.0 pips with a commission of around $6 per lot, making them competitive for active traders.

What is the minimum deposit required to open a Vantage account?

The minimum deposit at Vantage starts from $50 for Standard and Raw ECN accounts, while Pro ECN accounts require significantly higher deposits, often around $10,000.

What is the difference between Standard, Raw ECN, and Pro ECN accounts on Vantage?

Standard accounts are commission-free with spreads included, Raw ECN accounts offer lower spreads with a commission per trade, while Pro ECN accounts provide the tightest spreads and lower commissions but require a much higher deposit.

Conditions may vary by country and regulatory entity. Review the account details before registering.